Mirroring Characteristics:
- High Redundancy: Data is copied to two or three drives, depending on the configuration.
- Two-way mirror: Requires a minimum of 2 drives, data is copied to 2 drives.
- Three-way mirror: Requires a minimum of 3 drives, data is copied to 3 drives.
- Maximum Performance: Because data can be accessed from multiple drives simultaneously, mirroring provides excellent read performance.
- Low Storage Efficiency: Because data is copied, only 50% (two-way mirror) or 33% (three-way mirror) of the total drive capacity can be utilized.
Usage Example:
- OLTP (SQL Server) databases: Mirroring is perfect for workloads that require low latency and high reliability, such as database transactions.
- Critical Applications: Workloads that require high availability and tolerance for drive failure.
2. Parity: More Efficient Storage
Parity is a storage method that utilizes mathematical calculations to protect data, similar to RAID 5 or RAID 6.
Parity Characteristics:
- More Efficient Storage: Parity requires less space for redundancy compared to mirroring. For example, in RAID 5, only one drive is used for parity, so storage efficiency is increased.
- Good Read Performance: Parity offers good read performance, but its write speed is slower due to having to compute and store parity data.
- Adequate Redundancy: Parity can handle the failure of one or two drives, depending on the configuration used.
Usage Example:
- File Sharing & Backup: Parity is perfect for workloads that require large capacity but don’t require high write speeds, such as file storage or backups.
- Data Archive: A workload that prioritizes storage efficiency over performance.
3. Hybrid Mode: A Combination of Mirroring and Parity
Hybrid mode combines mirroring and parity advantages to achieve a balance between performance and storage efficiency. In this mode, frequently accessed data is stored by mirroring, while infrequently accessed data is stored with parity.
Characteristics of Hybrid Mode:
- Performance and Efficiency Balance: Data that requires high performance is stored on SSDs with mirroring, while data that requires large capacities is stored on HDDs with parity.
- Flexibility: Allows customization according to workload needs.
Usage Example:
- Virtual Machine Storage: Hybrid mode is ideal for virtualization environments where some VMs require high performance (stored on SSDs with mirroring), while others require large capacities (stored on HDDs with parity).
- Mixed Workloads: Workloads that have a combo
Workload-Based Usage Examples
| Workload Type | Recommended Configurations |
| Database OLTP (SQL Server) | Mirror for low latency and high performance. |
| File Sharing & Backup | Parity for long-term capacity and storage efficiency. |
| Virtual Machine Storage | Hybrid Mode for a balance between performance and capacity. |
Other Interesting Articles
Conclusion
Storage Spaces Direct (S2D) is a Software-Defined Storage (SDS) solution from Windows Server that is more flexible, scalable, and efficient than RAID. S2D supports three main configurations: Mirror for high performance and maximum redundancy, Parity for capacity efficiency, and Hybrid Mode that combines the two.
With NVMe, SSD, and RDMA networking support, S2D offers high speed and ease of management without the need for additional devices such as SAN/NAS, making it more cost-effective. If you’re looking for a reliable, flexible, and easy-to-manage storage solution, S2D is the best choice for your Windows Server infrastructure!